
I just finished watching "Billy Madison" and I thought I'd write my analysis since it's about schooling.
In case you've never seen the movie I'll give you a little background. Adam Sandler plays Billy Madison, an unmotivated and seemingly dumb adult who skated through school thanks to his rich father. Due to Billy's lax attitude he can not take over his father's company. He makes a deal to pass grades 1-12, each in 2 weeks, and if he is successful then he will take over the company.
I feel Billy's 1st grade class is not an accurate portrayal of what 1st grade should be. The teacher does do a good job of embracing individuality and ensuring all students feel like "special people" but there is a lack of academic subject matter. The classroom is filled with round tables, colors and decorations which I find potentially distracting for students (especially those with ADD or similar attention issues). The children sit and listen to story time but all fall asleep. I feel that if one student falls asleep it may be acceptable to let them sleep because there is a reason they need the sleep, but when the whole class, there's a problem. The movie also portrays lots of arts and crafts, but no math or science. This grade shows a positive portrayal of how school should instill confidence and individuality, but no academic substance.
In 2nd grade there is a drastic change. First you notice the teacher is older, less free spirited, and quiet. She keeps a traditional classroom with straight rows of desks and not many decorations which is very stereotypical of traditional schooling which some may feel is old and outdated (hence the age of the teacher). There is a spelling bee with the words bath and cheese and a final word of couch. I was surprised at the simplicity (except couch which is understandably confusing with the u making a w sound), but after researching I found that these words are accurate with the 2nd grade spelling level. I guess I overestimated the cognitive level of the majority of 7-8 year olds.
Third grade is where a big leap in curriculum occurs. Billy makes a comment about the fact that there is now social studies and division and how hard it will be. The classroom shows a good combination of traditionalism and cooperative learning through the students desks arranged in rows of pairs with more decorations than 2nd grade. This class, which turns out to be the best for Billy, is obviously taught by an older 20s to young 30s beautiful female teacher (see the trend of stereotypes here?). But there are a few flaws with this teacher's behaviors. First she decides to discipline Billy by pulling his ear and dragging him into the hallway to speak to him about his unacceptable actions in the classroom. This is an action that would have parents in an outrage. Another behavior that is unacceptable on the part of the teacher is when Billy could not write the z's in cursive in the name Ruzzuto she suggested he try writing the word buzz in a very condescending way. Now I understand why they put it in (to develop the plot of the teacher not approving of Billy's opportunity to come to school due to his father's money), but it represents a teacher targeting a student's insecurity and diminishing his confidence and motivation which is an act that can diminish a student's desire to achieve during their school career. A neat little observation is that the class field trip seems to be to the Old Bethpage Village Restoration which is a place that I attended on class trips and volunteered during their fairs. It's fun to see a place you know so well in a movie!
In 9th grade the students take chemistry, which I have never found to be the first science subject students take in high school. Anyway, the teacher is attempting to explain something related to chlorophyll by telling a story using the vocabulary in creative ways. I find this to be a useful technique, but unfortunately the students are uninterested.
There is also a decathlon of high school subjects in which they have events such as solving math problem using a complicated formula, baking a pie, a running race, a chemistry experiment, playing a musical instrument, performing a monologue of a Shakespeare play, and finally questions in the following topics: reflections in society and literature, business ethics, automobile repair, calculus, Shakespeare, needlepoint, architecture, chemistry, astronomy, and the Roman empire. I found these topics interesting to be picked out to represent high school. You often find some of these topics integrated in other curriculums and in some schools automobile repair and home economics are electives. In any event, these topics are important to expose all students to.
Now for a little analysis of some characters. The principal is portrayed as incompetent. He only gains control of an out of control classroom by asking and not his mere presence in the room. A principal should establish a demeanor of authority which is respected. The principal was also revealed as a former wrestler who killed a man. This should have been cleared before he even stepped foot in the building for an interview. The O'Doyles are a group of brothers that appear in every grade Billy is a part of. They are the typical bullies. The movie shows them chanting "O'Doyle's rule!" while falling off a cliff. It represents how in the end bullies lose and don't gain anything by preying off others. Billy realizes he was also a bully when he was originally in high school and he obviously didn't succeed the first time around.
What's the end result of Billy's experience? He decides to go to college to be a teacher, the typical irony.
Yes I know I completely overanalyzed a comical movie featuring Adam Sandler who is notorious for being stupidly funny. Don't get me wrong, I still enjoy Adam and his parading like an idiot and I still give the movie a thumbs up for entertaining me on a night where nothing else worthwhile was on tv. Thanks Starz!